For the past 3 years now, Put-in-Bay Pizza Co. has been serving delicious pizza and great food in Put-in-Bay Ohio. We are located just a cornhole bag throw away from downtown Put-in-Bay's thriving entertaiment district. We continue to be popular with locals and tourists, so much so that Putinbay.com's fans voted Put-in-Bay Pizza Co. as the Best Pizza on Put-in-Bay for the past 3 years! We are proud of our menu and encourage you to try our delicious new pizza this year with better crusts and better pepperoni! But don't take other people's word for it... come in and eat it for yourselves. Or call us for free delivery! (419) 285-0504

How Are We Different?

Hey... we love to make pizza! Fresh ingredients and a unique and innovative menu are some of the best reasons for Put-in-Bay Pizza Co's great taste. Our secret sauce recipe comes from a small family-owned chain in central Indiana. The owner used to work there as a kid and has brought that small town favorite here to Put-in_Bay for everyone to enjoy. We use the freshest high-quality cheeses and toppings, and use 100% whole milk mozzarella. We also have vegetarian pizzas, appetizers, grinders and salads to round out our menu.